The assessment of the applications is carried out in parallel by Vinnova (in Sweden) and AiF Projekt GmbH (in Germany). The processes differ to some extent. For the process for which Vinnova is responsible, the project that meet the formal requirements (section 6) will be evaluated on three criteria: Potential, Implementation and Actors.
What do we assess?
Assessment criterion: Potential
- The intended product, service or process responds to a need or demand in the market.
- How innovative the project proposal is in relation to existing solutions and ongoing major initiatives in the area.
- Competitiveness, that is, how the project result will affect the participants' knowledge, networks and/or business conditions, for example in the form of increased market shares or new competence / new long-term collaborations.
- The consortium's plan for continued funding after the project period, risk analysis and that the intended commercialization process is credible and has potential to lead to the market.
- The intended product, service or process has potential to contribute to environmentally and/or socially sustainable growth.
- How well the project proposal contributes to increased gender equality by integrating perspectives on sex and gender.
Assessment criterion: Actors
- The composition, participation, competence and ability of the actor constellation contribute to project objectives and implementation.
- The project manager and other key people have the conditions to lead and implement the project.
- potential of the international consortium/collaboration to provide clear added value during and after the project (compare with a national project).
- The company(ies) has the potential to reach the role and position in the industry/value chain required to exploit the project results.
- The composition of the project team and how the financial contribution, participation, power and influence are distributed equally between women and men in the project team.
Assessment criterion: Feasibility
- Budget, approach, project plan, risk analysis for project implementation are credible and relevant.
- Collaboration between the parties in both countries is necessary/important for the implementation of the project and for the parties to clearly benefit from the collaboration.
- The gender distribution in the project team and perspectives on sex and gender have been integrated into the project plan.
- The conditions for the project's results to be taken forward and used after the end of the project
- The project's strategy for managing intangible assets is credible
Applications that meet our formal eligibility requirements will proceed to assessment. In the assessment, we look at how much potential your idea has, how realistic it is and who will implement the project.
How do we judge in Sweden?
Once we have received the applications, we review them. Vinnova assesses the application documents that the Swedish coordinator has submitted. No additions or completions of application documents are permitted. We will discard all applications that are incomplete or do not meet our eligibility requirements.
The applications that are correct and complete are distributed among different evaluator and assessed in competition with each other. The evaluators are appointed by us based on their expertise in the field. Each proposal is assessed by at least three evaluator.
Please note that our German partner in this call for proposals the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Energy in Germany (here represented by AiF Projekt GmbH), has an assessment process that differs slightly from Vinnova's assessment process and the documentation requested. AiF Projekt GmbH does in some cases provide feedback and allows for additions during the decision-making process. Vinnova and AiF Projekt GmbH follow our respective guidelines regarding the assessment process.
When the evaluators have reviewed the applications in Sweden and Germany, Vinnova and AiF Projekt GmbH have a joint meeting to discuss which applications could be co-financed based on the evaluators' recommendations.
AiF Projekt GmbH and Vinnova carry out the evaluation of all applications received, based on each country's procedures, which differ in terms of which documents are accepted and the assessment process.
AiF Projekt GmbH and Vinnova carry out the evaluation of all applications received, based on the respective country's routines, which differ in terms of which documents are accepted and the assessment process. For Vinnova, the assessment is carried out by using internal and/or external experts appointed by Vinnova as evaluator. These assist Vinnova with qualified recommendations regarding the quality of the applications. Based on the outcomes of the respective national assessment process, AiF Projekt GmbH and Vinnova then make a joint decision on which project are to be financed.
How does it affect an organization's financial status?
Before we decide on funding we also make a comprehensive assessment of the organizational and financial status of those who receive funding.
We use information we receive from credit reports, currently from Dun & Bradstreet. We may also ask small and medium-sized businesses to demonstrate that they have the financial capacity to carry out the project.
In our assessment we check this:
- That organisations that are granted funding for payroll costs are registered as employers with the Swedish Tax Agency. If such registration does not exist when we make a decision, you must be able to show that a notification has been made. We do not approve retroactive registration.
- That organisations is not insolvent, or undergoing liquidation or corporate restructuring. You must also not have any significant unpaid debts with the Swedish Enforcement Authority.
- That the project manager is employed by the coordinating party in the project.
- That a limited liability company has not used up half or more of its share capital.